I want to tell you about a director I recently coached because I’d bet money you have someone just like her on your team right now.

She was up for a partner. Strong case, strong track record, the kind of person you’d bank on.

The panel didn’t say no. They said: come back and try again.

She showed up for our first call, still fighting for it. But underneath, something had cracked. She couldn’t tell me exactly what went wrong… just that it hadn’t landed the way she expected.

My job was to find out what “it” actually was.

I’ve coached enough directors through this exact moment to know it’s rarely random. The same four things show up, again and again.

1. All data, no story

Her case had plenty of facts. Numbers, details, history.

 What it didn’t have was a story. Something that pulled it all together and showed who she could become.

Right now, it only showed who she’d been.

2. Words matter too

I’ve seen brilliant people undersell themselves the moment they start speaking.

A lot of the time, it comes down to vocabulary… especially when English isn’t your first language.

Build that vocabulary, and suddenly your competence actually shows.

3. Engage, don’t present

Most people prepare a presentation.

But a partner panel isn’t an audience. It’s a room full of partners who’ve already done what you’re trying to do.

What they want to see is whether you can engage them… show them possibility, not just recap results.

4. Think like a firm

Some people stay narrow. Deep in their own specialty: cyber, forensics, whatever it is.

The ones who stand out can talk about the client, the market, the industry… the big picture.

And they can speak to everyone in that room, not just the ones who know their niche.

I told her: none of this is about how strong your case is.

It’s about how you show up in that room.

That’s the real gap between merit and success.

If you’re heading into a panel soon, here’s the part worth sitting with.

The instinct is to go build a stronger case. Add more wins. More reps.

But if you already have the numbers, and most people who get sent back do, that’s not the gap.

The gap is what happens in the room.

So here’s the question worth asking yourself before you walk in again:

Of these four, which one would move you furthest?

*** 

If this was helpful,

1.Subscribe to the CxO Sales Playbook

Every week, I share 1 actionable tip to get your sales teams to over deliver and quickly move deals over the line even in a slow economy.

2.Take Our Deal Review Quiz

Drawing from our work with multiple Fortune 500 clients, It’ll give you the exact probability of winning your deal & highlight specific areas of risk and concern – in under 90 seconds.

3.Review Our Clients & Case Studies

We’ve coached the sales teams of Fortune 500 & 100 companies such as Microsoft, SAP and Google.

Next Step 

Subscribe to the CXO Sales Playbook Newsletter.

Every Friday morning, I’ll email you 1 actionable tip to get your sales teams to overdeliver. (other benefits include a big bonus and company-wide recognition :).